In Focus Dialogue All articles
Housing & Planning

Five Reforms, One Shortage: Why Planning 'Radicalism' Keeps Underdelivering

In Focus Dialogue
Five Reforms, One Shortage: Why Planning 'Radicalism' Keeps Underdelivering

Photo by Photo by Modunite Ltd on Unsplash on Unsplash

Planning is the policy area where British governments most reliably mistake a press release for a policy. Each cycle produces a reform described as the most significant since the war; each cycle ends with a housing target unmet, a developer complaining about viability, and a local authority complaining about resources. Below are five changes from the past decade, including the proposals now moving through Parliament in 2026, that promised transformation and delivered something closer to administrative rearranging.

1. Permission in principle and the starter homes drive

The Housing and Planning Act 2016 promised 200,000 starter homes and introduced permission in principle — a lighter-touch route to establish that a site is suitable for housing before detailed approval. The theory was that certainty would unlock small sites and speed up delivery.

In practice, the starter homes programme was quietly retired, its funding recycled, and permission in principle was taken up patchily, concentrated in a handful of authorities and rarely used at the scale imagined. The obstacle it addressed — uncertainty at the earliest stage — was never the binding constraint. Finance, build costs, infrastructure capacity and the absence of a functioning small-housebuilder market were. Removing a procedural step in front of a blocked pipeline does not unblock the pipeline.

2. The standard method of assessing housing need

The revised National Planning Policy Framework and its standard method were meant to take the politics out of housing numbers by applying a formula. It did not take the politics out; it relocated them into the formula itself, where the assumptions were less visible and therefore harder to debate.

The method has been revised repeatedly, each revision producing winners and losers among local authorities and each producing a fresh round of plan-making delay. Planners interviewed for this piece were near-unanimous: local plans do not fail because the number is wrong, but because the evidence base, infrastructure assessment and examination process take years that authorities cannot staff. Tinkering with the formula changes the argument without shortening it.

3. The 2020 zonal revolution that never arrived

The Planning for the Future white paper proposed the most radical restructuring in a generation: a zonal system with automatic approval in growth areas, a national infrastructure levy, and a digitised, map-based plan. It was bold, coherent and almost entirely undelivered. Opposition from parts of the governing party's own backbenches, concern among environmental groups, and the sheer administrative difficulty of transitioning thousands of site allocations combined to strip the package down to a set of pilot programmes and a design code.

The episode is instructive less for what it proposed than for what it revealed: the reform agenda can be reversed by the same political weather that produced it. Developers and local authorities plan on a ten-year horizon, and a system that may be rewritten in eighteen months cannot supply the certainty it promises.

4. The permitted development expansion

Converting offices, agricultural buildings and retail units into homes without a full planning application has been the most durable reform of the period, extended repeatedly since 2013. It has produced homes. It has also produced homes in the wrong places, of uncertain quality, exempt from affordable housing contributions and sometimes from decent space standards.

The political appeal is obvious: it is devolution-free, council-free and delivery-visible. The deeper problem is that it treats planning as an obstacle rather than as the mechanism through which infrastructure, affordability and design are negotiated together. A reform that bypasses the system cannot fix the system.

5. The 2026 package: brownfield first, again

The proposals now before Parliament combine a presumption in favour of brownfield development, new towns designated through a faster route, and a renewed push on planning fee recovery. Each element has merit. None is new. The brownfield-first principle has been national policy in some form for two decades, and the constraints on brownfield delivery are well documented: remediation costs, fragmented ownership, and the fact that the most developable brownfield sites have already gone.

The genuinely consequential reform in the 2026 package is the least discussed — the move towards full cost recovery for local planning departments. Underfunded planning authorities are the quiet cause of much of the delay the system is blamed for. Whether the funding survives contact with the fiscal envelope is another matter.

What radical would actually look like

Asked what they would do with genuine political cover, the planners and small developers we spoke to pointed away from procedural reform entirely.

Capture land value uplift more systematically, so that infrastructure and affordable housing are funded by the change in land value that planning permission creates, rather than by grants that can be cut.

Fund local planning properly and permanently, so that authorities can maintain up-to-date plans, defend them at examination and negotiate rather than capitulate.

Rebuild the small and medium-sized builder sector through lending and site-servicing support, because a market dominated by a handful of large volume housebuilders will manage supply rather than expand it.

And accept that housing numbers require a public argument, not a formula. The formula has been tried for a decade. It has produced neither consent nor homes.

The uncomfortable conclusion is that none of these is a communications strategy. They are all slow, expensive and contested — which is precisely why they keep losing to reforms that can be announced in a single afternoon.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Handover Without a Handbrake: Who Answers for England's New Devolution Deals?

The Handover Without a Handbrake: Who Answers for England's New Devolution Deals?

Ribbon-Cutting Is Not a Strategy: The Case for Putting Repair First

Ribbon-Cutting Is Not a Strategy: The Case for Putting Repair First